Posted by
P.B. Christensen on
Apr 05, 2011; 12:43pm
URL: http://elecraft.85.s1.nabble.com/K3EXREF-and-Trimble-Thunderbolts-tp6242158.html
Those of you considering a GPS-disciplined oscillator for use with the
K3EXREF may be interested in this: I recently purchased two Trimble
Thunderbolts on the surplus market to compare against my HP 58540A and
Brandywine GPS4 units. After several days of testing, I'm retiring the HP
and Brandywine units. All devices have exceptionally good stability, but
the Trimble units consume far less power, run substantially cooler, and the
monitoring interface provides much more status information than the prior
units.
In recent discussions with John, KE5FX, he has performed phase noise
measurements across several GPS-DO units and even various oscillator brands
within the Trimble Thunderbolt model.
http://www.thegleam.com/ke5fx/tbolt.htmEarly Thunderbolts use a Piezo Corp. OCXO and when combined with GPS
correction, its phase noise performance is good but not exceptional. By
contrast, the Trimble-branded OCXO offers phase noise performance several
degrees better than most other GPS-DO units near Fc. The area between 1 Hz
and 100 Hz is usually a good indicator of the overall phase noise
performance. It's not easy getting good numbers that distance from Fc.
Although the phase noise performance will not carry over to the K3, it's an
important parameter if the GPS-DO will be used in other applications or
other transceivers that phase lock onto the 10 MHz external reference.
Some suggestions:
1) Look for Thunderbolts with a year 2004 Rev. E stamp. These use the
better quality OCXO units with the Trimble-branded label. KE5FX has sampled
several from this batch. As noted, early units with the Piezo-branded OCXO
are worse in terms of phase noise performance. I do not know the OCXO
quality of recent units;
2) You will see Thunderbolts in a high quality case where an internal DC-DC
converter is used. My recommendation is to avoid being tempted by the nice
looks and what may be perceived as a "better" unit. I can almost guarantee
that the switch-mode converters will present noise problems with your K3
receiver -- and seen on your panadapters. I've been down that road with
other GPS-DO units and ultimately, I scrapped the converters and fed them
with linear supplies. Stick to the basic ugly OEM Thunderbolt module and
feed it from a triple-output linear supply;
3) Power supplies: I like OEM/off-board supplies by PowerOne, Condor, and
International Power. They offer excellent performance and low noise. I am
using an International Power IHBAA-40W. Also look for HBAA-40W. The user
must add a fuse, power cord and wiring harness. It's a little more work,
but you get a lot of performance for the money;
4) Look for sellers who will accept offers. Both my Thunderbolts were
purchased for USD $70 ea and a small shipping change.
Even if you have no plans to use K3EXREF, get one anyway as a precision
frequency reference for your station.
Paul, W9AC
______________________________________________________________
Elecraft mailing list
Home:
http://mailman.qth.net/mailman/listinfo/elecraftHelp:
http://mailman.qth.net/mmfaq.htmPost: mailto:
[hidden email]
This list hosted by:
http://www.qsl.netPlease help support this email list:
http://www.qsl.net/donate.html